Understanding Claim Ratios in Health Insurance: A Complete Guide
Selecting the right health insurance policy in India involves much more than comparing premiums and coverage benefits. These key financial indicators provide valuable insights into the insurer’s reliability and financial health, directly impacting your experience as a policyholder.
In this article, we delve into the significance of CSR and ICR, how they are calculated, and why these ratios should play a vital role in your health insurance decision-making process.
What is the Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR)?
In simple terms, it indicates the percentage of claims successfully settled by an insurer compared to the total number of claims received or processed within a specific period.
The standard formula for calculating CSR is:
Claim Settlement Ratio = (Total Claims Settled / Net Claims Processed) × 100
Where:
-
Net Claims Processed is calculated as:
-
Claims Outstanding at the Beginning of the Year
-
Claims Received During the Year
− Claims Outstanding at the End of the Year.
-
Alternatively, some institutions calculate CSR based only on claims received and settled during the year without adjusting for pending claims, although this method may not present an accurate picture of claims efficiency.
For the most reliable CSR figures, it’s recommended to consult official resources such as the IRDAI Annual Report, which provides audited claims data for all insurers in India.
Why CSR Matters
-
Indicates Reliability: A high CSR suggests that the insurer has a strong track record of settling claims.
-
Enhances Customer Trust: Policyholders can feel more secure knowing claims will likely be honoured.
-
Reflects Operational Efficiency: Efficient claim settlement procedures often translate into quicker and smoother processing for customers.
What is the Incurred Claim Ratio (ICR)?
The Incurred Claim Ratio (ICR), on the other hand, measures an insurance company’s financial stability. It represents the ratio of claims incurred by the insurer against the net premium collected during a specific period.
The formula to calculate ICR is:
Where:
-
Net Claims Incurred refers to the total amount paid towards claims, including outstanding claims provisions.
-
Net Premium Earned is the total premium collected after deductions such as reinsurance costs.
Why ICR Matters
-
Indicates Financial Health: A very high ICR could imply potential financial stress, while a low-to-moderate ICR reflects better profitability and stability.
-
Helps Assess Sustainability: Companies with extremely high ICRs may struggle to maintain claim pay outs, affecting long-term policyholder interests.
-
Influences Premium Revisions: Insurers with consistently high ICRs might increase premiums to maintain profitability.
Key Differences Between CSR and ICR
| Parameter | Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) | Incurred Claim Ratio (ICR) |
|---|---|---|
| Focus | Number of claims settled vs processed | Amount of claims incurred vs premium earned |
| Indicates | Efficiency in settling claims | Financial stability and sustainability |
| Customer Impact | Trust and ease of claim processing | Assurance of insurer’s ability to pay claims long-term |
| Desirability | Higher CSR is better | Moderate ICR (not too high or too low) is preferable |
Why CSR and ICR Should Influence Your Health Insurance Choice
Before finalizing a health insurance policy, reviewing CSR and ICR statistics can help you assess:
1. Reliability of the Insurer
A high CSR signifies that the insurer settles most claims, suggesting a reliable and customer-centric approach—crucial when you need swift claim approvals during medical emergencies.
2. Financial Soundness
An insurer’s ICR reveals its financial discipline. A company consistently paying out more claims than the premium collected (very high ICR) may face financial strain, while an insurer with an extremely low ICR might not be providing sufficient claim benefits.
3. Customer Satisfaction
Higher CSR combined with a balanced ICR generally translates into higher customer satisfaction rates, ensuring a smooth and hassle-free claims experience.
Ideal Range for CSR and ICR
-
Ideal CSR: 85% and above.
-
Ideal ICR: Between 60% and 90%.
-
Less than 60%: May indicate fewer claim payouts.
-
Above 90%: Could suggest financial distress due to high claim volumes.
-
Industry Overview: CSR, ICR, and Claims Ageing Analysis (FY 2021–22)
A comparative review of private and public sector insurers based on IRDAI’s 2021–22 Annual Report and official public disclosures:
| Category | Insurer | CSR (No. of Claims) | CSR (Amount Settled) | % Claims Settled <3 months | ICR |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Private Insurers | HDFC Ergo | 95.64% | 85.49% | 98.49% | 97.47% |
| Private Insurers | Bajaj Allianz | 94.30% | 88.79% | 96.59% | 90.64% |
| Private Insurers | ICICI Lombard | 87.97% | 67.95% | 97.07% | 91.67% |
| Public Insurers | New India Assurance | 99.75% | 111.70% | 92.93% | 124.54% |
| Standalone Health Insurers | Star Health | 82.50% | 60.50% | 99.06% | 87.06% |
| Standalone Health Insurers | Niva Bupa Health | 90.86% | 67.70% | 99.99% | 62.12% |
(Note: Figures are for the fiscal year 2021–22 and may vary in subsequent reports.)
Observations:
-
HDFC Ergo and Bajaj Allianz show a good balance between high CSR and manageable ICR, reflecting efficiency and stability.
-
New India Assurance has an excellent CSR but a high ICR, indicating higher claim outflows relative to premiums.
-
Standalone health insurers like Star Health and Niva Bupa Health maintain healthy settlement rates and reasonable ICRs.
How to Check CSR and ICR of Health Insurers
-
Insurer Public Disclosures: Insurers publish claims data (Form NL-37) on their websites.
-
Trusted Insurance Portals: Reputed online aggregators often compile and present CSR and ICR data for comparison.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Why is Claim Settlement Ratio (CSR) important when choosing health insurance?
A higher CSR boosts confidence that your claim will be processed smoothly when needed.
2. How does the Incurred Claim Ratio (ICR) impact my health insurance choice?
A very high ICR could hint at future financial challenges, affecting policyholders.
3. What is the ideal CSR and ICR to look for?
Prefer insurers with a CSR above 85% and an ICR between 60% and 90%, ensuring a balance between high claim settlement and financial stability.
4. Where can I find reliable CSR and ICR data?
Refer to the IRDAI Annual Report, insurers’ official public disclosures, or credible insurance comparison websites for updated and accurate information.
5. Why should I check both CSR and ICR instead of just one?
While CSR shows how efficiently claims are settled, ICR provides insights into the insurer’s financial health. Together, they offer a comprehensive view of insurer performance.
Conclusion
When choosing a health insurance plan, focusing solely on premiums or coverage could lead to missed red flags. Evaluating an insurer’s Claim Settlement Ratio and Incurred Claim Ratio equips you with essential insights into their reliability and financial robustness.
A high CSR ensures that your claims are likely to be honoured without hassles, while a balanced ICR assures that the insurer is financially sound enough to support claims over the long term.
Make sure to always refer to the latest IRDAI Annual Report or the insurer’s official disclosures for the most accurate and updated figures.
Choosing the right health insurance is not just about protection; it’s about ensuring that when you need support the most, your insurer stands firmly by your side.